Drawing: Good Art’s Vital Ingredient

Last updated: March 31, 2026
Words by
Prefer Jackson's Art on Google

Is drawing skill fundamental to being a good artist?  If you can’t draw can you still be an artist?

Is drawing of primary importance in making an artwork – before other considerations like colour and mass of form?

The other day these 2 questions were emailed to me. It was suggested that I discuss these ideas in a blog post, and ever since I have been suffering from cold sweats and shivers! Where to start? The whole broad subject of the importance of drawing has been written about for centuries, and indeed I have very much enjoyed reading a number of brilliant essays to get my ideas flowing for this post. The essays reminded me of my own practice, of my experiences at Art School, and the experience of looking at a number of key works of art – and so it is reference to these very personal anecdotes that I choose to contribute to this never-ending debate.

First and foremost, to answer both of the questions above I feel it’s important to try and shed some light on what drawing is. On the Victoria and Albert Museum website there is a fantastic article (which includes a huge array of thought provoking quotes about drawing – from Leonardo da Vinci right through to the fashion designer Alexander McQueen)­­ and it lists the reasons why people draw as being the following:

1. To visualise thought and work something out

2. To provide a pattern to follow or give instructions how to make something

3. To help clients visualise what is proposed

4. To describe or record something

5. To give pleasure as ends in themselves

For artists, I would say that reasons 1, 4 and 5 are the most common reasons for drawing, with reasons 1 and 4 seemingly being the most ‘classical’. It was during the Renaissance that the term ‘Disegno’ (which is often translated into the word ‘drawing’) described the process of describing a form in line and not colour, as well as a means of developing an idea. We keep sketchbooks to document what we see and admire on a day-to-day basis as well as to turn little acorns of ideas into the big oak tree of an idea – perhaps a more accomplished drawing, or a painting, sculpture, or installation.

Before Modernism, good drawing meant something very different to what it means now. Modernism brought about the dawn of a state of consciousness in artists – suddenly artists could play the role of God rather than simply strive to imitate Him. Before Modernism, good drawing replicated the beauty of God’s great work. This is why the debate ‘Disegno e Colore’ was so pressing in Renaissance times – Vasari, Michelangelo, da Vinci…they all needed to understand how best to give thanks to God in the most technically sound works of art – was it through line, or through colour? As indicated in the words of Leonardo da Vinci himself, “‘the young man should first learn perspective, then the proportions of objects. Next, copy work after the hand of a good master, to gain the habit of drawing parts of the body well; and then to work from nature, to confirm the lessons learned” – there was a structure to the training, and a rigidity to what was considered good.

Since Modernism, the definition of good drawing has evolved and ever continues to do so. Tracey Emin is the Royal Academy’s Professor of Drawing and I am pretty certain the RA’s founder Joshua Reynolds would have had something to say about that! A good draughtsman in the realm of contemporary fine art is no longer judged by how well they can draw anatomy…the field has broadened. Drawing isn’t just pencil or charcoal on paper, it is also drawing on Microsoft Paint or Photoshop, and it can also be 3 dimensional. So how is drawing skill defined? Here are a few quotes from a few Post-Modernist artists to guide us.

“My drawings do not try to imitate life, they try to create life, to invent life” – Keith Haring

“I lasso thoughts with a pen. I draw a stave church or someone from Hello! Magazine not because I want to replicate how they look, but because of the meaning they bring to the work” – Grayson Perry

“Drawing is rather like playing chess: your mind races ahead of the moves that you eventually make” – David Hockney

“Even as a kid in drawing class, I had real ambition. I wanted to be the best in the class, but there was always some other feller who was better; so I thought, ‘It can’t be about being the best, it has to be about the drawing itself, what you do with it.’ That’s kind of stuck with me” – Damien Hirst

“I know when something I’ve done is good. I don’t suppose everyone would agree with my critical decisions but I don’t show the discarded stuff to anyone. The editing decisions I make are intuitive, but if I had to attach a criteria to the process I would say I tend to keep the things that surprise me and chuck the things that don’t – David Shrigley

“It took me years to understand the magic of drawing. For years, I tried to make things look how they are – instead of being what they are. Drawing is an alchemic language. Some of my favourite drawings I have done with my eyes closed – or so drunk I do not remember making them” – Tracey Emin

On reading these quotes it strikes me that many contemporary artists see their good drawings as almost having a life of their own; they ‘create life’, ‘they bring meaning’, ‘alchemic language’… the good drawings are formed when something unexpected occurs in the process. The artist has the idea and intention to create a drawing, but they are not wholly aware or in control of the whole process – the subconscious seems to come into play and a good drawing transcends the original intention. Not only is it a response to what the eyes see but it is also a response to what the soul sees.

When asked what I consider a good drawing my standard answer is that a good drawing communicates – it speaks to us. I believe that the quotes above indicate that a good drawing, before it speaks to the public when hung on a gallery wall, actually speaks to the artist too – it holds a mirror to the artist’s subconscious and tells us how we feel within, and it surprises and intrigues. I believe it is a way of really seeing something and a means of accessing the spiritual, and possibly has more in common with classical art than we may think – it is giving form to the emotional world, which is just as much a part of our world as the material or natural world.

So, is drawing skill fundamental to being a good artist? Can you make good art without allowing this alchemy to happen?

At this year’s Hay on Wye festival the director of the Serpentine Gallery, Julia Peyton-Jones made the argument that artists did not need to know how to draw in order to make good art. “I’m not sure it really matters now…I don’t feel that this ability to do something is really an appropriate test now of whether you’re an artist. Yes, some great artists demonstrate sublime skill but they also do other things. That’s the way the world is now, other things are possible. It’s not just limited to one form of expression” she is reported to have said. But she isn’t an artist. The art critic William Packer responded “”What I find so depressing at the moment is that when one looks at so many people coming out of art schools now – even those who are brave enough to put up a painting – is how technically impoverished some of it is. This is the great problem that faces us. If you’re going to become a ballet dancer it’s unthinkable that you don’t have to learn the steps first. Can you imagine an earnest violinist who thought the scales are terribly inhibiting?” And with this I think he has hit the nail on the head.

Drawing is a way of seeing. It is a way of slowing down the process of looking. It is a way of revealing how you really feel about existing in your environment. It is also about exploring your ideas, taking them on a journey, meditating, scrutinising. Without a structure, a form, a drawing, all you have are half formed ideas, the passion, the texture of paint or of clay, the emotion of colour, the sequences of film footage, but with no depth to the thought of how these qualities are going to communicate your idea, your rationale. It’s like having a string of words without a sentence structure – it means less. You don’t have to draw like da Vinci to make good art. But if you want to make art that speaks to the soul, that inspires, that has depth and sophistication, you can guarantee that you will have access to this potential through an investment in drawing.

With thanks to the following articles:

 ‘Disegno e Colore: The Reconciliation of Two Rivals in the Art of Keith Haring’ – http://www.haring.com/!/selected_writing/disegno-e-colore-the-reconciliation-of-two-rivals-in-the-art-of-keith-haring#.U_x7mMVdV9I

‘Disegno e Colore: Art Historical Reflections on the Structuring of Space’ by Rein Undusk – http://www.eki.ee/km/place/pdf/kp5_03_undusk.pdf

‘Artists no longer need to be able to draw or paint to be great’ – http://www.telegraph.co.uk/culture/hay-festival/10862412/Artists-no-longer-need-to-be-able-to-paint-or-draw-to-be-great.html

‘What Is Drawing?’ –  http://www.vam.ac.uk/content/articles/w/what-is-drawing/

Lisa Takahashi has been a contributor to the blog since 2013 and a Jackson’s team member since 2006. Her love of art materials spans oils, watercolours, acrylics and relief print techniques. Alongside her writing she regularly exhibits her artwork, and teaches linocut and painting in Bristol and Somerset.

6 COMMENTS

LEAVE A COMMENT

6 thoughts on “Drawing: Good Art’s Vital Ingredient”

  1. Nice article, I tend to agree that drawing doesn’t need to now be part of an artwork, there are so many other ways for artists to articulate their thoughts, however it is a nice skill to have and the ability to draw will never inhibit a true artists creativity. However I find it is the amateur and semi professional artist who really lacks drawing skills and relies ever more so on the photograph as the source of their art while at the same time criticizing “modern” art for its apparent lack of skill (what ever that is). The photo often provides the superficial look of a studied scene without the bother of the artist actually learning to draw. Walter Sickert said the only artists who should use photos are those who don’t have to, and you can see what he means. However those who don’t draw are missing a bit part of being an artist, it is not about turning out more pictures into the world, it is about finding out how the world is put together and drawing enables us to look out of ourselves and not be trapped in an introverted art of personal expression. This I find is the true value of drawing.

    1. I absolutely agree with your articulate response – and it’s such a good point you make about the copying of photographs hindering true response to a subject…my heart sinks every time I see a drawing of a figure that is so lifeless and flat, and you can tell that the reason why is the source material. I really do think Sickert’s point is spot on. I wish I could disagree with you to keep the debate going, but I can’t! I guess the ultimate crux of the argument is, you may not have to be able to draw to make good art, but that particular ability never going to hinder!

      1. I think there are three ways of using photographs in an art work. One is to take a picture and copy it: whether this creates something lifeless and flat or uniquely new depends on the artist and their skills of selection and interpretation. I’d guess this is the use that you’re both talking about. Another way is to take lots of shots and use them as a reminder of the scene and whatever captivated one at the time. The artist can then create something new without directly copying any aspect of the pictures themselves. A third way would involve the artist looking at creating the photograph as an artwork in itself: studying the scene, it’s aspect and lighting and capturing just what it was that contained the essence of that scene. Creating a print or painting from that photograph would be, in effect, creating a separate piece of art.

        Drawing is just one skill that any artist can or cannot have in their toolbox. Any end piece of art depends on the skill and vision of the artist, not their source material, whether a drawing or photograph. An artist who is a skilled draughtsman may produce a great drawing as an intermediate step, something that feeds into the final work. But an artist who is a skilled photographer may do the same with a photograph. And one who is skilled at looking, seeing and selecting, may make dozens of snaps as their intermediate product. The end result is what counts, not the steps to get there.

        1. Absolutely, but I guess what we’re attempting to determine is whether drawing from photographs can hinder the attempt to make good art. I still think Dennis Spicer had a good point via the words of Walter Sickert – and I think the path to good art involves the alchemy that occurs when the process fully engages with the idea and creates images that surprise the artist as well as the viewer. Some might say that is giving flesh to the subconscious, or making the spiritual visual, but whatever it is, it is that sense of elevation one feels when one has managed to make a good piece of art that keeps me trying, and I’m sure keeps many other artists trying too.

  2. “many contemporary artists see their good drawings as almost having a life of their own; they ‘create life’, ‘they bring meaning’, ‘alchemic language’…”

    Alternatively, some contemporary “artists” have found a wordy way to distract from their inability, not just to draw but to “do art” of any significance. The wordiness of purveyors of Emperors’ New Clothes.

    1. Possibly, yes, but that seems a rather sad viewpoint! Ok you may not view the artists I quoted as good artists, but I thought it was interesting to see that the magic of drawing as described by great modernist painters such as Sickert, Matisse, Picasso, and even younger artists such as Hockney and Freud, is felt in much the same way as so many Post Modernist artists. Postmodernism did not kill off all traditional values in art. You might argue that these ‘less talented’ artists have merely adopted the beliefs of their forefathers to add gravitas to their insubstantial works, but I still find it hugely encouraging and inspiring that so many well known, often controversial artists, are vociferous in their belief that drawing is as important as it always has been.

Comments are closed.

YOU MIGHT LIKE

Scroll to Top