Need to decide which is the best paint for you?
Watercolours, acrylics, oils and pastels are each inspiring and exciting in their own way. Which set of marks, textures and colours will inspire you?
Oil Paints

Oil paints have a richness that is unparalleled. Finely ground pigments are carefully milled into a drying oil, usually linseed but sometimes if it’s a pale colour safflower or walnut oil. Different pigments have different particle sizes and absorbency, which means that some paints end up being more saturated, thicker or with a greater staining capacity than others. Oil paint is slow drying which means colour can be blended on the support – how you might imagine a sky by Constable would be painted. The ability to move and lift colour with a rag can lend the painting process an almost sculptural quality, as in ‘Impression, Sunrise’ (1873) by Claude Monet, where traces of lifted colour remain and exist alongside thicker applications of paint. Rubens-esque flesh tones can be created with layers of delicate glazes. Buttery impasto effects can be built up in thick layers to create rich colour and texture, effects that may bring Van Gogh’s ‘Starry Night’ to mind. Paints are thinned and brushes cleaned with the use of artist’s solvents such as turpentine or Zest-It. Drying times can be sped up with the use of alkyd mediums or driers so you really don’t have to wait around if you need to quickly capture the likeness of your sitter or the first light on the hills. Water-mixable oils get around the problem of needing solvents, while oil sticks allow you to draw straight on to canvas with pure colour and discover a direct, tactile and expressive way of working.
Cons: Slow drying, require solvents
Acrylic Paints

Acrylic is the state of the art choice for today’s most modern painter, and is made from pigment suspended in an acrylic resin. It is possible to formulate resins to different degrees of fluidity, which explains the many different varieties of acrylic paint available. As with most acrylic mediums, most resins when wet have a milky appearance that turns clear as it dries. This causes a colour shift; as the paints dry the ‘milkiness’ disappears and the paints appear darker. Some painters who are looking to match a previously used colour mix find this a problem. However for versatility it’s hard to beat. No other kind of paint offers as much room for customisation – there are gels, pastes and fluid mediums that allow you to alter sheen, drying times, transparency, and texture – and it’s also possible to combine mediums and paint ranges to give your paint the exact qualities you’re looking for. Acrylic is great for mixed media artists as it creates a stable ground for almost all wet and dry media and with no solvents required for painting or clean-up, it’s a convenient choice for those painting in the home.
Cons: Naturally fast drying, true longevity of paints has not been tested, colour shift from wet to dry paint can make colour matching difficult
Watercolour Paint

Cons: Colours are not as saturated as oils or acrylics, less mark making variety
Soft Pastel

Cons: Finished work can be fragile, very few mediums to control behaviour of pastels
Once you’ve chosen what paint you’d like to work with…
…the next decision to make is which brand? Mixing brands within a medium is fine so if you like the sound of several, why not try a few? Often brands will have characteristics unique to them e.g. Professional Acrylics by Winsor and Newton have no colour shift, and Schmincke Mussini oils are made with natural resins. Paints are categorised as being professional (the highest pigment to binder ratio), artist (slightly less pigment than professional but usually made using the same processes) or student quality (reliable paints made with just enough pigment to make vibrant work possible).
8 thoughts on “Which Paint? An introduction to oils, acrylics, watercolour and pastel”
DEAR LISA. Hello my name is Desmond
and I was wondering if you could very
kindly help me out please..I was
wondering if you could very kindly tell
me please if watercolour or arcylic
paints are the best to start painting.. I’m
trying to get as much information as I
can do before buying…I will many be
painting animals and landscape and
what to try and make them more life like
and realistic…I suffer from asthma and
allergies and I was wondering if you
could very kindly give me as much
information you can about what one be
better for me…thank you so much and
any information you could send me will
be very much appreciated..yours
sincerely Mr Desmond Townsend
Dear Desmond
One is not better than the other for starting out – just go with your instinct, and which you like the look of best. I suggest searching on the internet or in books paintings of animals and landscapes that you aspire to making yourself and seeing which medium they were painted in, and go from there. As for asthma and allergies…it depends what your triggers are. If you need to avoid gum arabic then I would steer clear of watercolour, but some people may need to steer clear of the acrylic polymers used in acrylic paint. However both watercolour and acrylic can be thinned and washed with water, and there is no need for heady solvents such as turpentine and/or white spirit, which are often triggers for those with respiratory and dermatology issues.
Many thanks
Lisa
Dear Lisa
I am a beginner
painter at age 75.Finding the
proper medium has been
challenging for me.Landscspes
that are somewhat contemporary
is my theme of desire .Holding a
brush using a knife or just using
pastels is the question to capture
true colors.Softness appeals to
me the most. Arthritic hands do
get in the way sometimes. Exact
Detail of leaves flowers branches
structures are not of concern just
soft referances. Acrylics or
pastels is the question.
Thank you kindly
Ben B
Dear Ben
Thanks for your question. As it is art we are talking about, there is no definitive answer, however, if you have any experience of drawing then you may find pastels easier to start with – all the mixing happens on the paper, and you can easily blend colours with your fingers. Some people don’t like to feel and mess of chalky pastels – if you think you might fall into this category then I would suggest acrylics!
Many thanks
Lisa
Dear Lisa
I’m an absolute beginner in painting. I’ve
never had any experience with art, but
painting really did interest me since a
long time. Since this is completely new
to me, i don’t know how to start. My
question is what kind of painting is the
best for beginners and what kind of
materials should i use (the brand, the
type,etc). I know there’s no definitive
answer but I’d be glad if you could give
me some suggestions. Thanks in
advance.
Dalin
Dear Dalin,
My own personal advice would be to invest in a set of watercolours. They are available in pans (solid cakes of paint) and tubes – pans are probably easiest to get a handle of. Buy what you can afford, but a set of colours in any brand will give you good variety and an idea of the kinds of colours you most like to paint with. A lot of the sets available come with a brush and colour mixing area in the lid, which would be fine to start with. You can buy more brushes when you start to get an idea for the kinds of marks you like to make.
You’ll also need a pad of watercolour paper, and you might like to get a hard pencil and eraser so you can sketch your composition lightly prior to painting.
If you search the following terms on jacksonsart.com you’ll be able to see an extensive choice within the suggestions I’ve made.
watercolour pan set
watercolour pad
H pencil
In addition to these essentials, you’ll need some kitchen towel and a water pot.
Hope this helps!
Many thanks
Lisa
Hi Lisa!
I love to paint but I’ve only used acrylics
thus far. I’d love to learn to use oil paints,
but I’m wondering what kind of materials I
need for that? If I need a solvent or any
tips for starting out with oils?
Hi Melanie,
You might find this article of use – https://www.jacksonsart.com/blog/2013/11/04/all-you-need-to-know-to-get-started-in-oil-painting/
The bare minimum you will need to start painting are some brushes, an oil paint-suitable surface (such as primed canvas, primed wood, aluminium or oil painting paper), solvent (artist’s white spirit, turpentine, Gamsol or Zest It would all work!) a palette (wooden, plastic, glass or tear-off) and some rags. The article above goes into a little more detail!
Many thanks
Lisa
Comments are closed.