Why choose Artist Quality Watercolour Paint over Student Grade?

Last updated: March 31, 2026
Prefer Jackson's Art on Google

After reading Ann Cahill’s review on jacksonsart.com of Jackson’s Artist Cadmium Yellow Orange Watercolour saying this ‘is a really lovely mellow orange yellow… very good for botanical work as most oranges I’ve tried are really quite harsh.’ Ann Cahill is a professional gardener who uses painting as a way to really “see” plants. We asked her to elaborate on her review and she started talking to us about why she transitioned from student grade to artist watercolour paint.


Contents

The Limitations of Student Grade Watercolours

The Behaviour of the Watercolour when Lifting from the Pan

Mixing Botanical tones with Schmincke Horadam Watercolours

Why Paying Attention to the Pigments in Watercolour is Important

Advice on which Artist Watercolours to Buy First

Pros and Cons of Buying Artist Watercolour Sets

Conclusion

About Ann Cahill


w&n-cotman-pack
Winsor & Newton Cotman Watercolour Travel Set

Transitioning from Student to Artist quality Watercolours

By Ann Cahill


The Limitations of Student Grade Watercolours

As an amateur I was, initially, quite happy with my box of Cotman watercolours. Painting almost exclusively Irish landscapes. West of Ireland at that. Which meant soft dull colours… the landscape seen through the mist of typical August bank holiday weather i.e. wet and windy.

Split Rock, Easky as an example of muted landscape using W&N Cotman watercolours
Split Rock, Easky as an example of muted landscape, by Ann Cahill, using W&N Cotman watercolours

It was only when taking a garden design course, and I was trying to do some illustrations of potential gardens, that I realised the limitations of student quality watercolours. To any professional artists out there it’s obvious, but I had to learn this for myself. If the colour wasn’t already there in the set, then trying to mix it from pans, very few of which were single pigment colours, meant that most mixed colours ended up dull and muddy. Of course I take responsibility here, I am an untrained dauber. Still, if you wish to inspire a customer to go ahead with spending money on a new garden design, it does help if the garden design were not to seem constantly swathed in the mist of “West of Ireland August bank holiday weather”.


horadam-actual-set
Schmincke Horadam Watercolour Sets

The Behaviour of the Watercolour when Lifted from the Pan

Looking for better pigments, I initially tried a couple of W&N artists colours but the real revelation of the upgrade came when I splashed out on set of Schmincke Horadam paints (half pans). The colours were amazing, especially the cadmiums. The problem now was that the darker colours were so pigment rich, I couldn’t immediately tell what colour each pan was without making a colour chart. (The Cotman set colours were obvious on sight.)

showing artist watercolour schmincke-swatches
Swatches of Schmincke Horadam Watercolour

Without doubt one of the main joys of using artists grade paints is how well they lift from the pan even with just a damp brush. Here I would say that Schmincke Horadam are superb. The Jackson’s Artist watercolour are also very good in this respect, especially considering their very reasonable price. I have found the W & N artists pan paints are comparatively hard to take up on the brush and, when using tubes, hard to reactivate once dried on the palette.


3greens
Swatches of Schmincke Watercolours Sap Green, Hookers Green and Viridian

Mixing Botanical Colours with Schmincke Horadam Watercolours

As a learner I had made myself a book of watercolour mixes using combinations of the paints I had. I was especially keen on developing a range of greens because greens for foliage are rarely, if ever, “sap” or “hookers green” or “Viridian”. I spent quite some time producing pages of greens, reds, pinks, purples, browns, greys, blues, chromatic blacks and so on. After I bought my Schmincke Horadam set I felt like throwing that book out the window and starting again! It was slightly like using a different language.

I still kept my Cotman set, but without the paints. The little spaces are now full of paints poured in from tubes. In fact, the little plastic box is so light, it is ideal for painting en plein air, especially if I’m not even sure I’m going to paint anything when out on a walk.


showing artist watercolour daniel-smith-moonglow
Swatch of Daniel Smith Moonglow Watercolour

Why Paying Attention to the Pigments in Watercolour is Important

Apart from Schmincke Horadam, which are probably my favourite, I have tried Daniel Smith watercolours. I’m ashamed to say I am easily entranced by the names alone. How could I resist “Moonglow” which was described somewhere as the perfect colour for the shadows on clouds. It is, indeed, a gorgeous deep lilac tinged grey, but so far from my experience if I mix it with any other colour it makes a brown soil colour. Moonglow is already a mix of a blue, a green and a red pigment…. So now I pay more attention to the pigments listed. I have spent numerous sessions on the internet looking through the pigments listed on www.artiscreation.com which gives me far more information than I need or can remember but it is fascinating. (The website doesn’t actually show you the colour by the way.)

showing artist watercolour JJackson's-Premanent magenta
Swatch of Jackson’s Permanent Magenta Artist Watercolour made from the pigment PV19

Of course, I now realise that even knowing the pigment colour is not sufficient. Take PV19, Quinacridone Violet, this has numerous marketing names. I have been seduced by the various names, Ruby Red (Schmincke), Quinacridone Rose (Daniel Smith), Permanent Rose (Winsor & Newton), Permanent Carmine (Schmincke again) all turned out to be single pigments PV19 and all slightly different. Still, as one botanical artist said, “You can never have too many pinks…”

showing artist watercolour Jackson's-lamp-black
Swatch of Jackson’s Lamp Black Artist Watercolour

Some of the names given to the paints indicate their origin, such as lamp black, but even here not all lamp blacks are the same. Schmincke Horadam is Pbk6, Daler Rowney Artists’ is Pbk7 and W&N a mix of the two. Now, I know that most artists will not use black as you can get better results adding a complementary colour, or mixing up your own chromatic black. The reason I was interested in lamp black is because I had read that in bygone days portrait artists would paint on a ground of mixed white, lemon yellow and lamp black which gives a slight olive tone, perfect for Caucasian skin in shade. This does require the “right” lamp black, however (with a blue undertone), which, according to me at least, is Pbk 7 – at least Daler Rowney’s lamp black works. Having said that, I have yet to do a portrait in watercolours… it’s just that every time I watch Sky Arts Portrait Artist of the Year I look across at my husband and think… I really must have a go…… after all, he’s just sitting there!

showing artist watercolour daniel-smith-sleeping-beauty-turquoise
Swatch of Daniel Smith Sleeping Beauty Turquoise Watercolour

I can understand how some artists like to have a wide range of colours premade and available in pan or tube, to save time and experimentation, and for that, the Daniel Smith range is very evocative. Whilst the hypocrite in me loves Moonglow, some of the other names, for example, “sleeping beauty turquoise green” which seem to be their made up names for minerals they have ‘rediscovered’ are just plain annoying.

adelabreton
Watercolour by Adela Breton of the east façade of the ‘Nunnery’, with the ‘Church’ at Chichén Itzá, both buildings heavily decorated and with hook-nosed masks of the rain god Chac, Photo credit: Dan Brown/Bristol Museums, Galleries and Archives

Again the hypocrite in me has to admit that I can see why their Mayan series are called that, after I visited an exhibition in Bristol last year of the large scale watercolour copies of Mayan wall paintings/reliefs the explorer Adela Breton made in the Nineteenth century. I will also add that some of Daniel Smiths mineral paints are gorgeous such as genuine amethyst. However, whilst some paint names do annoy me, I wouldn’t want to rely on a Pantone-like system of numbers only.


showing artist watercolour genuine-amethest
Swatch of Daniel Smith Genuine Amethyst Watercolour

Advice on which Artist Watercolours to Buy First

It’s all too easy to get carried away with new paints, and especially as there are so many in the artists’ ranges. If you are still using student range paints and are not sure if the artists’ ranges are worth the extra money, may I recommend starting with one or two of the heavy metal pigments, the cadmiums and the cobalts. These are often so vibrant and pigment rich that a little goes a long way. Mixing with these colours is truly a revelation. If I had to choose one colour to start with, I’d go with Schmincke’s Cobalt Turquoise which is a perfect colour in itself, hard to beat, but it is in the mixing that it shows why it’s a series 4, i.e. expensive paint. Just the sheer range of greens from acid green to “deep in a dark forest” kind of green (yes, I made that name up – didn’t I say I was a hypocrite?) which is very useful for anyone interested in botanical or landscape painting.


showing artist watercolour shmcincke-cobalt-turquoise
Swatch of Schmincke Cobalt Turquoise Watercolour

Pros and Cons of Buying Artist Watercolour Sets

Although sets are an expensive outlay, they are often cheaper than buying the colours individually. The downside to sets is that there are usually colours included that you wouldn’t have chosen yourself (I have yet to use the silver or gold from my Schmincke set – yet. They generally have a good palette of cool and warm primaries plus the usual earth colours. As for using pans versus tubes, I generally prefer the pans (especially Schmincke as their paints are so easy to lift off) but I sometimes buy a tube colour and using an empty pan will give some of it away to a friend to try out….. especially if it is a series 3 or 4.


showing artist watercolour greengoldschmincke
Swatch of Schmincke Green Gold Watercolour that replaced Schmincke 536 Green Yellow (discontinued in 2017)

Conclusion

I recently bought two new Schmincke colours, perhaps unconsciously chosen because they were pretty much complementary, I sketched these pears using only these two colours. I was surprised with what I could do with these two alone, and that despite they were both were made up of two pigments. Ultramarine Violet and Green Yellow.

Pair of Pears watercolour
Pair of Pears watercolour by Ann Cahill

I’m sure most readers of Jackson’s Blog will understand exactly how little pans or tubes of luscious and delicious colour can create excitement and enjoyment even when ‘playing’ with the colours themselves, never mind what can be created using them. That pleasure and enjoyment is so much greater when the colours are artist quality.

showing artist watercolour shmincke-ultramarine-violet
Swatch of Schmincke Ultramarine Violet Watercolour


About Ann Cahill

Ann Cahill is an amateur artist who is currently teaching herself and experimenting with different media and approaches. She does plant drawings as a means of really “seeing” the plants that she works with as a professional gardener. She uses her own illustrations for her garden designs if her customers are redoing beds/borders/whole gardens, and they need help envisioning what it might look like.


Shop Watercolours on jacksonsart.com

showing artist watercolour

A former member of the Jackson’s Blog team, Tegen wrote about projects within the world of contemporary art, whether it’s kick-starters, conceptual activism or exhibitions. In her own work her focus lies in experimentation, and unearthing the true potential of the materials she works with.

6 COMMENTS

LEAVE A COMMENT

6 thoughts on “Why choose Artist Quality Watercolour Paint over Student Grade?”

  1. As a fellow color addict, I too couldn’t go
    back to student grade. The level of
    vibrancy you get from artist color is just
    impossible to attain in most student
    brands.

    Regarding Sleeping Beauty Turquoise, it’s
    named after the mine of origin, the
    Sleeping Beauty mine in Arizona, which
    closed in 2012. While I think some of
    these Primatek pigments are more
    romantic than useful, I find the names,
    while often obscure, do mean something.

    1. Tegen Hager-Suart

      Hi Stacey, that’s really interesting about the etymology of sleeping beauty turquoise, I had no idea – what an interesting name for a mine as well.

  2. adam hammond

    I think a important thing to mention is
    within professional paints you have
    super high quality and and lower end like
    for example I use turner’s which are not
    great for lifting but great for me but they
    are affordable

    1. Tegen Hager-Suart

      Hey Adam, that is a very good point and it’s definitely worth seeing it as a sliding band rather than as a completely distinct group.

  3. A wonderful thing about artists quality
    colors is the fact that they go much
    further than student grade. The artists
    grade may cost 3x+ per tube but each
    tube(of the same amount) will go 5x
    further if not more. Factor in the quality,
    lightfastness, etc and it’s a no brainer to
    go with artists colors. I prefer Sennelier
    and Jacksons.

    1. Tegen Hager-Suart

      Hi Joshua, thank you for your input and for saying you prefer our and Sennelier’s watercolours. We completely agree that investing in artist colours can be economically sound in the long term.

Comments are closed.

YOU MIGHT LIKE

,

Creating Textural Effects with Watercolour Mediums

Schmincke Retro Horadam Watercolours: Gamboge Gum, Solferino, and Cassler Brown

,

Art Through Symbols: Fire

Scroll to Top