Before the introduction of commercially-made paints, artists or their apprentices would make handmade watercolours from scratch using pigment and a binder. The first mass-produced watercolours were introduced in 1780 and were sold as hard cakes that needed to be dipped in water and rubbed to release the colour. At the beginning of the 19th Century, moist watercolours became available in porcelain pans and in 1846, tubes of watercolour paint entered the market (following the introduction of tubed oil paints in 1841). These advances were revolutionary and played a direct role in the development of the impressionist movement, as well as opening up new possibilities for plein air painting. Today, it can be difficult to imagine a time when artist colours were not available to buy readymade.
Some artists still choose to make their paints by hand which, while more time-consuming than picking up a tube from an art supplies store, is a great way of getting in touch with the properties of different pigments.
What are Watercolour Paints Made From?
Watercolour is made up of finely ground pigment suspended in a binder made of gum Arabic, distilled water, and other additives to preserve and stabilise the paint. Every watercolour manufacturer has a unique formula and method of production, which is why there can be such a difference in consistency and handling qualities between brands. Manufacturers of professional quality watercolours will also adjust the formula to account for the characteristics of each pigment in their range.
Artists who make their own paints have their own recipes which they will have fine-tuned over time. The following is a list of ingredients that I used to make handmade watercolours in the Jackson’s studio, some are available from jacksonsart.com, and others can be found in a supermarket or pharmacy.
Gum Arabic Solution
Gum Arabic is a watersoluble gum which is extracted from the acacia tree, and it acts as the glue that binds the pigment. Some artists make their own by dissolving gum Arabic pieces in distilled water, but we also stock gum Arabic solution which is ready to use.
Honey
Honey is an ingredient in many ranges of watercolour, including our own Jackson’s Artist Watercolours. It is a humectant which helps the paint retain moisture and re-wet after drying. Honey is also a natural preservative and a plasticiser, meaning that it increases the flexibility of gum Arabic (a naturally brittle binder) and prevent cracking in the pan after drying. Runny honey is best, rather than the harder variety.
Glycerin
Like honey, glycerin is a humectant and a plasticiser which can be bought at a pharmacy (it is a common ingredient in skincare products). I used both honey and glycerin in my binder because I find too much honey to be very sticky, but either glycerin or honey would work on its own.
Clove Oil
A natural antibacterial and antifungal agent, clove oil (usually sold as clove essential oil) is an excellent preservative which stops the paint going mouldy.
Dry Pigment
Our new range of Artist Pigments consists of 100 colours, all of which are suitable for making handmade watercolours. 10g is enough to make around 1-2 full pans of watercolour (depending on the pigment), so it is an ideal size if you are trying out a new colour. For larger volumes of paint, they are also available in pots of 100g.
Some pigments, like Cadmium and Cobalt pigments, are toxic and known to be hazardous when inhaled or ingested. Other pigments, like natural earth pigments, are considered less toxic, but no matter what pigment you are using, avoid breathing in the dust by wearing a face mask over your mouth and nose. Latex gloves should be worn to protect your hands, as pigment can easily get under your nails. Avoid eating and drinking around dry pigments and keep out of reach of children and pets.
Making Handmade Watercolours
60ml of gum Arabic solution, one teaspoon of glycerin, one teaspoon of honey, and one drop of clove oil was decanted into a glass bottle and stirred well.
One tablespoon of dry pigment was placed in the middle of a tempered glass palette. Many artists who make their own paint prefer the grinding surface to have a fine tooth, and this can be created by making a paste with medium grit carborundum powder and water, and grinding it into the surface with a muller until the surface is frosted. This helps you mull the pigment extremely finely.
The pigment I used was Cobalt Cerulean Blue (PB36), one of my favourite pigments in watercolour because of its softly granulating properties. Using a palette knife, I made a well in the middle of the mound of pigment. With a pipette, I dropped 5ml of the pre-mixed binder into the well.
Using the palette knife, I gently folded the pigment into the binder, mixing as much as I could before adding more binder incrementally until all of the pigment was incorporated and the mixture had a yoghurt-like consistency. The amount of binder needed varies greatly depending on the pigment used, as some pigments are more ‘thirsty’ than others.
With a glass muller, I slowly ground the pigment/binder mixture in a circular motion, spreading it across the glass palette in a thin layer in order to mull the pigment as finely as possible. At this point, if the paint is too stiff to mull smoothly, more of the binding mixture should be added.
How long the paint should be mulled depends on the pigment. Some pigments, like the natural earth pigments, have larger pigment particles and need more time to mull finely than those with smaller particles. I tested the paint along the way by taking a sample on the edge of the palette knife and swatching it. There are a couple of things to look out for when testing handmade watercolours.
- If the dried paint is dusty and smudges when you run your finger over it, it suggests that there is not enough binder in it, so it needs a little more binding mixture and more mulling.
- If the paint is very shiny or cracks when you bend the paper, there is too much gum Arabic in the mixture and more pigment should be added.
Swatching is the most reliable way to know when to stop mulling. The consistency is not so much of a good indicator, as some pigments make more fluid paint, while others make a heavier-bodied paint.
After around 30 minutes of mulling, I was happy with the result. My first tests were a little chalky and very granulating, but as it was mulled more and more, the Cobalt Cerulean Blue developed a slightly greener hue and had more clarity. Using a palette knife, I scraped the watercolour paint from the glass palette, and dispensed it into a full pan.
Handmade watercolours aren’t as smooth and creamy as shop-bought colours which are milled with a machine, but each has its own character! In the above image are three handmade watercolour pans with very different consistencies – Quinacridone Magenta and Natural Sienna Monte Amiata made heavier-bodied paints, as they have a higher pigment to binder ratio. Cobalt Cerulean Blue turned out more fluid and self-levelling. Regardless of consistency, each re-wetted well after drying. Some pigments, like earth pigments, have a tendency to crack when dry in the pan. Adding more honey and/or glycerin to the mixture can prevent or reduce cracking.
For larger volumes of paint, watercolour can be stored in a tube. To find out more about filling paint tubes, read our blog post on the subject. It focusses on oil paint, but the same principle applies and we stock 14ml empty aluminium tubes which are a good size for watercolour.
Watch our film to see watercolours being made in the studio:
Visit jacksonsart.com to find the materials used in the article:
- Jackson’s Artist Pigments
- Gum Arabic Solution
- Glass Palette
- Glass Mullers
- Palette Knives
- Pipettes
- Empty watercolour pans
You can find other products related to watercolour painting, such as brushes, paper, and paints, in our watercolour category.
Further Reading:
The Secrets of Making Jackson’s Professional Oil Paint
David Coles on Colour, Pigments, and Paintmaking
The Story of Ultramarine Blue and French Ultramarine
Shop Jackson’s Pigments on jacksonsart.com
Oh my goodness as always you have
inspired me to try and make my own
watercolours with your pigments! I have a
question though can the pigments be used
for other things like making Calligraphy
inks? I want to make my own calligraphy
inks and was wondering if these pigments
would work for that…
Hi Simone, thanks for your question. It’s not something I’ve tried before, and I think that some pigments that have very large pigment particles (like natural earth pigments) wouldn’t be suitable. But I’m sure that hansa yellow, quinacridone magenta, quinacridone violet, phthalo green and phthalo blue pigments would work because they are often used in pigmented inks! Do let us know how it goes!
Hi, can 2 different colored ground
pigments be mixed together in the glass
to form another color. Tyty
Hi Judy, yes absolutely you can combine pigments. You can create some really interesting paints this way
Very interesting!!
I have a question. If one wanted to mix a
color but store it Ina tube– is that
possible as well and if so what
adjustments would one make for the
ratio of liquids? And any tips on filling
and closing paint tubes?
Hi Risa, apologies for the delay getting back to you – our post on filling paint tubes should help you. I keep the pigment/binder ratio the same when filling both tubes and pans.
HI Evie, thank you so much for this
article, I have tried to make my own
watercolors for a while but you answered
my question of why would pigment and
gum arabic start smelling incredibley bad
after a while. I did not know I have to add
clove oil! Until now I only mixed the
pigment (without even grinding them!)
with gum arabic dissolved in water , and
sometimes just a bit of gum arabic,
dpending on the effect I was after, but I
think I will gretaly improve the quality
following your advice! Thanks again,
can’t wait to try this.
I’m so glad the article was helpful, Marianna!
I’m so glad to fine your article!
Twenty
years ago I bought some cobalt violet
pigment from Kremer in NYC and
have
never used it!! I vaguely knew what I
needed to do, but never did. Thanks
for your clarity. I have enough cobalt
violet to last the rest of my life and
am glad I can now use it.
Thanyou
Very interesting‼️
You’re welcome! Thanks for your comment.
Hey Evie
Thanks for this article, it now inspires me to
want to try making my own watercolour
paints
Thank you, Simone!
Would you consider doing an article for
making encaustic paints too? I’ve been
thinking of using white beeswax and
Luster wax as a base. Many folks use
damar resin which adds some yellow. I’m
especially interested in wax emulsions,
but also wax medium bars.
Thanks for the suggestion, Jon! I’ve never tried making encaustic paints but I’d love to try it and write about it!
What a fascinating article! I am on the committee to organize the Virginia Watercolor Society annual meeting which includes a statewide judged competition and optional workshop in Richmond, VA, USA, at the end of this month. I wonder if we could have permission to reproduce this and give handouts of this wonderful article to each of the 20 people who have signed up for our workshop with Fred Graff? Of course, if you have printed copies available, I would be happy to purchase them from you for this purpose. Not all our members are computer-oriented even in this day and age. 🙂
Dear Janet
Apologies for the delay in replying. We would be delighted for your to print the article out, so long as the URL (website address, jacksonsart.com/blog) is mentioned on each print out.
Many thanks
Lisa
Bonjour,
J’aimerais savoir si les pigments peuvent
être utilisés pour fabriquer des émaux
céramique donc résister à une cuisson à 900
ou 100 dégrés?
Merci pour votre question, je contacterais un céramiste pour savoir quels pigments il me conseillerait.
thank you for this detailed explanation,
my question is that there is a dosage of
arabic gum for each type of pigment
Hi Ahmed, I’m afraid there isn’t an exact dosage for each pigment (as even pigments that have the same pigment number can vary greatly).
What a super explanation of the
process of hand-making paints. I may
not do so myself (but one never
knows) but it’s such a wonderful thing
to do. With the range of high quality
dry pigments and additional materials
all from Jackson’s one can only
imagine beautiful results and happy
accidents. Not to mention the
pleasure of working with your own
paints.
Thank you, Sue! Making your own paints is very rewarding!
What a terrific article. I want to make
paint using natural ochres I collected
from early 20th Century ochre pits. A
rough trial with pigment plus gum
arabic painted on well. Onwards!
Thanks.
Hi Bev, that sounds incredible! Would love to know how you get on. Thanks for your comment!
A most informative and interesting article
Thank you for this
No problem, Tony. Thanks for your comment!
I’m interested to know – Can you make
other types of paint with these
pigments? Are acrylic, gouache or oil
possible to make for example? I need to
take paints abroad for a long trip where
they are not readily available, but need
to keep my luggage weight down and
would rather not risk spillages on route.
Hi Lily, yes you can make any kind of paint with these pigments. The same general principle applies, but with a different binder. I find acrylic a little more tricky to make because it dries so quickly.
Brilliant article thank you! I have been
wanting to make my own paints for a
good while now. If I were to follow this
example but only use Glycerin and no
honey, would I just replace the quantity
of honey with extra glycerin?
Hi Louise, I’m sorry for the delay answering your question. Yes, if you’re using only glycerin I’d replace the amount of honey with more glycerin. I hope that helps!
I plan on filling half pans, how long
should I allow it to dry before gout to
someone.
Hi Tina, it depends on the pigment used and how much binder is used. You should find that the pans are dry to the touch within a couple of days at the most. Bear in mind that if a lot of honey is used in the binder, the pans may remain tacky. You could place a piece of greaseproof paper over the pan if that is the case.
Can I get a formulation for erasable ink.
Hi Stanley,
I’m afraid we do not have a formulation for erasable ink, although we know that there are two ways of making ersable ink – with rubber cement or thermosensitive agents…. but we can’t offer any further information I’m afraid. Do any of our readers have any experience of making erasable ink?
Many thanks
Lisa
When I look up clove oil, my brief search
turns up essential oil. Is there a difference,
or do you speak of the same thing?
Hi Fiona, yes it’s clove essential oil. I’ll amend the post to clarify!
Thank you so much for clarifying –
Much appreciated!
Hi Evie,
Thank you for this wonderful article. I
recently made my very first batch of
handmade watercolor paints! I found the
mulling process to go very well however, my
final product definitely had some noticeable
issues. The flow of the paint was not as
smooth and I noticed it was lifting very
easily (I had a hard time creating a smooth
gradient because my brush was leaving
streak-like marks). Additionally, I noticed
that while the paint was wet, it was kind of
“bouncing back” slightly. I recognize that it
will take time to fine tune my recipe
(particularly the binder). I’m wondering if you
have any thoughts about how to improve
fluidity and smoothness when re-wetting?
My first binder recipe I used 2:1 distilled
water, Gum Arabic, and 1/5c honey, 1 TBS
glycerin, 2 drops clove. Thank you!!
Hi Lily! I know exactly what you mean, I’ve noticed it in some of my handmade watercolours – particularly with certain pigments (cobalt pigments, for example, don’t diffuse very actively). I would recommend adding a couple of drops of ox gall to the binder (or a synthetic alternative which works just as well). This should improve the flow and the streak-marks. It also sounds like the paint needs to be milled for a bit longer. As you say, it takes time to fine-tune the process and each pigment needs to be treated a little differently. I hope that helps!
Hi,
thank you so much for this informative article!
I recently got into paint making so I’m inhaling lots of tutorials at the moment. My first batch has been sitting for over a month now and hasn’t dried yet, although it was mulled long enough and looks great on swatches- how long does the paint in your pans usually take to dry? I tried finding information on this, but the drying process seems to be something people don’t talk as much about, so I’m kind of nervous… thank you for this!
Hi Alice, I’m so glad you enjoyed the article. How ‘wet’ are they? If the binder includes a lot of honey or glycerin, or if there isn’t enough pigment in the mixture, then the paint may remain very tacky in the pan. There have been a couple of pigments I’ve used where the paint didn’t dry at all and remained completely liquid in the pan (Malachite and Azurite – both mineral pigments) but I didn’t find that it affected the quality of the paint.
Is there a way to get them to dry? Like
maybe adding more arabic powder? I
have a few pans that are not drying
(been a week) and I don’t know what to
do!
Hi Michelle! It sounds like they might need to be formulated with more pigment and less gum arabic. If they contain a lot of honey or gylcerin that will also keep them wet.
Hi, great article.
Would it be possible to make liquid
watercolours by this method? Would
Any ingredients have to be replaced?
Many thanks!
Hi Neil! Yes you can make liquid watercolours using the same method and ingredients. You can fill tubes with the watercolour paint, and as long as the tube is airtight the paint will remain liquid. I find that there can be some separation of binder and pigment in the tube, particularly with earth and cobalt-based pigments, so some colours might need to be stirred with a cocktail stick before squeezing the paint out.
Hi, i want to know can i use fabric
powder pigments with binder are they
safe. Also other inks and pigments like
concrete pigments can we use them?
Please help me. I m new here
Fabric powders are usually dyes, made to dissolve in water, not be little particles like pigment. Dyes are usually not as lightfast as you want for paints, when you want the artwork to last for 100 or more years. So fabric dye powder would probably not make a lasting paint.
Concrete pigments might be more appropriate for art paints as they are more likely to be lightfast and my understanding is that they are based on iron oxides, which are also in artists paints. But I don’t know what the particle sizes are, are they fine enough for watercolours? And it may be that they have a limited colour selection if they are iron oxides, because it would then be many different shades of browns.
Jackson’s make artists quality pigments that are perfect for making your own watercolours or other paints.
Jackson’s Artist Pigments. Small pots start at just £1.80 and we ship internationally.
Hi there, I would not recommend advising
the use of one’s finger to test lifting. The oils
in the finger can sabotage the result. One
should use a paper towel or piece of paper
for best results.
You’re right Stacey! That’s a bad habit I’ve got into
Not to worry Evie – it is so tempting to
do. I have to resist so often. Hehe!
Hi there,
I found this article because I was looking for gum arabic. Nice to read. I would like to add that the mulling process is not ment to mill the pigment (i.e. break up big granules into smaller) because this is done with pestle and mortar before starting making the paint. But most artistic pigments you buy are ready to work with and don’t need milling anymore. Would you like to forage your own ochers or some other rocks to make paint with, this would definitely need milling and elbow grease.
That said, the mulling, which you do with the glass muller on the slab is meant to bind the pigment particles with the binder, to make sure that each and every particle is incapsulated in binder. This is what makes the paint ‘stick’ to watercolour paper.
I hope you don’t find this too pretentious, but i thought this clears the difference between milling and mulling and the importance of good mulling.
Thanks for the clarification, Heidi!